The Great Debate:  Soaking or not soaking grilling wood chips?

The Great Debate: Soaking or not soaking grilling wood chips?

The decision of whether to soak grilling wood chips before using them is a subject of debate among barbecue enthusiasts. Both methods have their advantages and disadvantages, and the choice ultimately depends on personal preference and the specific cooking situation. Here are the key points to consider for each side of the debate from Papa Ken at Maine Grilling Woods.

Soaking Wood Chips:

  1. Smoke Control: Soaking wood chips can help control the rate at which they produce smoke. Wet wood chips smolder and release smoke more slowly than dry ones, which can be useful for achieving a milder, more controlled smoke flavor. If you prefer to soak your chips in a flavored liquid such as Spiced Rum than that flavor will be released prior to the actual smoking.

  2. Extended Cooking Time: Soaked wood chips generally last longer during the cooking process, providing a steady source of smoke over a more extended period. This can be advantageous for slow-cooking methods like smoking or when grilling for an extended period.

  3. Reduced Flare-Ups: Wet wood chips are less likely to catch fire or produce flare-ups on the grill, making them a safer option, especially when grilling with fatty meats.

  4. Milder Smoke Flavor: Soaked wood chips tend to produce a milder smoke flavor, which can be preferable when you want a subtle smokiness in your food.

Not Soaking Wood Chips:

  1. Quick Ignition: Dry wood chips catch fire more quickly and easily, producing smoke almost immediately. This can be beneficial when you want to infuse your food with a robust smoky flavor from the start.

  2. Intense Smoke Flavor: Dry wood chips produce a more intense and immediate smoky flavor. This can be desirable for grilling techniques like high-heat searing, where you want a strong smokiness in a short amount of time.

  3. Convenience: Not soaking wood chips saves time and effort, as you don't need to wait for them to soak before using them on the grill.

  4. Varied Results: Depending on your specific cooking situation and the type of wood chips you're using, not soaking them may yield more varied and unpredictable results, which can be exciting for experimentation.

In summary, the choice to soak or not to soak grilling wood chips comes down to your cooking goals and personal preferences. If you prefer a milder, more controlled smoke flavor, and want to reduce the risk of flare-ups, soaking is a good option. On the other hand, if you're seeking a stronger, immediate smoky flavor and value convenience, using dry wood chips may be the way to go. Ultimately, you can experiment with both methods to see which one works best for your specific grilling and smoking needs.  Enjoy!  Papa Ken

Back to blog

Leave a comment

Please note, comments need to be approved before they are published.